When You Need Implicit Differentiation
Some curves cannot be written as y = f(x). A circle x² + y² = 25 gives two values of y for most x, and the folium x³ + y³ = 6xy cannot be solved for y in any tidy way. Implicit differentiation avoids the problem: differentiate both sides as they are, treating y as an unknown function of x.
The one rule to remember is the chain rule. Whenever you differentiate a term with y, you get an extra y′ (dy/dx): d/dx[y²] = 2y·y′.
The Five-Step Method
- Differentiate both sides with respect to x.
- Attach y′ to every derivative of a y-term (chain rule).
- Collect all y′ terms on one side.
- Factor out y′.
- Divide to isolate it.
x² + y² = 25, find dy/dx
- Differentiate: 2x + 2y·y′ = 0.
- Move: 2y·y′ = −2x.
- Divide: y′ = −x/y.
Answer: dy/dx = −x/y
Tangent to x² + y² = 25 at (3, 4)
- Check the point: 9 + 16 = 25 ✓.
- Slope: −x/y = −3/4.
- Point-slope: y − 4 = −(3/4)(x − 3), which simplifies to y = −(3/4)x + 25/4.
Answer: Tangent: y = −0.75x + 6.25. Normal slope: 4/3
A Harder Example: the Folium of Descartes
Find dy/dx and the slope at (3, 3)
- Differentiate: 3x² + 3y²·y′ = 6y + 6x·y′ (product rule on 6xy).
- Collect y′: 3y²·y′ − 6x·y′ = 6y − 3x².
- Factor and divide: y′ = (2y − x²) ÷ (y² − 2x).
- At (3, 3): (6 − 9) ÷ (9 − 6) = −1. Check the point: 27 + 27 = 54 = 6·9 ✓.
Answer: dy/dx = (2y − x²)/(y² − 2x), slope −1 at (3, 3)
Descartes proposed this curve in 1638 to test Fermat’s method of tangents. Three hundred years on it remains a good stress test because the answer depends on both x and y.
Second Derivative Implicitly
Differentiate y′ again, then substitute the first result and, if possible, the original equation to simplify.
x² + y² = 25, find y″
- y′ = −x/y. Differentiate with the quotient rule: y″ = −(y − x·y′) ÷ y².
- Substitute y′ = −x/y: y″ = −(y + x²/y) ÷ y² = −(y² + x²) ÷ y³.
- Use x² + y² = 25.
Answer: y″ = −25/y³
The sign tells you something real: at the top of the circle (y > 0) y″ is negative, so the curve is concave down, and at the bottom it is concave up.
What We Think Is Overrated, Underrated and Wrong
Worked Examples With Real Numbers
For the circle x² + y² = 25, differentiate both sides: 2x + 2y·y′ = 0, so dy/dx = −x ÷ y. At (3, 4) the slope is −3/4, and the tangent line is y − 4 = −(3/4)(x − 3), or 3x + 4y = 25.
For the folium x³ + y³ = 6xy: 3x² + 3y²y′ = 6y + 6xy′, so dy/dx = (2y − x²) ÷ (y² − 2x). The tangent is vertical where y² = 2x.
Our Take: What Is Overrated, Underrated and Plain Wrong
Overrated: solving for y first. Many curves cannot be solved for y, and implicit differentiation does not need to.
Underrated: a slope check at a known point. On a circle, the slope must be perpendicular to the radius.
Plain wrong: forgetting the y′ factor. d/dx y² is 2y·y′, not 2y.
Implicit Differentiation Mistakes That Cost Marks
- Forgetting y′ on a y-term: d/dx[y³] is 3y²·y′, not 3y².
- Missing the product rule on mixed terms like xy.
- Not checking that the point lies on the curve.
- Dividing by zero: a vertical tangent occurs where the denominator is 0 (y = 0 on the circle).
- Mixing up the tangent slope and the normal slope (negative reciprocal).
Why Students Get Stuck on Implicit Differentiation, and What a Good Calculator Should Do
Searching for help with implicit differentiation usually starts late at night with one problem that will not work out. Y is a function of x, but it is hidden inside the equation. A good calculator fixes that by showing each step, checking its own answer and explaining the idea in plain words. This section covers what students struggle with, what they want, and how this page responds.
In short: students need to differentiate both sides and solve for dy/dx, not just see a final number, and a calculator earns trust only when its steps can be checked.
Understand the pain points
What students get stuck on
Most mistakes here are not about arithmetic. They come from one rule applied the wrong way round, which is why seeing every step matters.
- Forgetting the dy/dx factor on every y termFind dy/dx for x^2 + y^2 = 25↗
- Dropping the product rule on terms like xyFind dy/dx for x*y = 1↗
- Not collecting the dy/dx terms before solvingFind dy/dx for x^3 + y^3 = 6xy↗
- Making sign slips when isolating dy/dxFind dy/dx for y^2 = x^3↗
Understand the frustrations and desires
What they feel, and what they want
Each frustration points to a wish: a clearer step, a built-in check, an explanation in plain words.
- Wants each y term flagged with dy/dx
- Wants the final dy/dx simplified
- Wants the slope at a given point
Build the page around their intent
Each intent has a place on this page
The page follows intent, not features, so each need has a clear starting point.
- I need an answer now: type the problem into the calculator at the top of this page.Find dy/dx for x^2 + y^2 = 25↗
- I need to understand: the sections below explain the idea in plain words and list the common mistakes.
- I need to check my work: every step is shown, so the first line that differs from yours is the one to study.
- I need practice: open the solver, tap + and choose Create Practice Test.
- I need it explained aloud: in the solver, tap + and choose Create Video.